Peter was the son of Carsten Burfiend and grew up at his father's farm about a mile and a half northwest. He and Jennie left this farm in 1891 to take over that property, so it's easy to confuse the two sites. A family recollection says Jennie discouraged Peter from fishing after his brother drowned; Peter was also known for skilled broad-ax and adze work that he sometimes traded with neighbors.
The farm later passed through Olsen, Miller, and Basch families before its sale to the park in 1977. The Basches kept using it for 25 more years.