At the top, the trail makes a roughly quarter-mile loop around the island’s summit crater, locally called the Witches Cauldron. It is a smaller volcanic bowl inside Crater Lake’s much larger caldera: look over the rim into the island’s own crater, then turn back toward the blue water and the steep caldera walls. The views change as you circle, so give the loop time instead of stopping at its first opening. For a photo, keep a piece of the crater rim or a bleached tree trunk in the foreground with the lake beyond; a frame full of water loses the island’s scale.
A separate spur drops into the crater. It is short, but steep and loose, and can be slippery; it is not part of the measured 2.4-mile hike. The summit loop gives you the defining view without taking that descent.