Thomas and Martha Pearce lived in this district with their eight children. Thomas, a butcher from Geelong, partnered with Robert McConachy to buy the Angahook run; local histories date two bark huts there to 1852. Thomas died during a winter creek flood, and the family could not get him across the swollen water to a cemetery, so he was buried on a cliff top. Martha was later buried beside him. Their grave is elsewhere, on the Surf Coast Walk west of Split Point Lighthouse, not at this reserve.
Ash Wednesday bushfires destroyed the hut in February 1983. Local accounts disagree on whether the present hut is a replica or a rebuilt original, and give 1985 or 1986 as the rebuild date, so its exact material history remains unsettled.