St Michael & All Angels is a medieval church, principally 14th- and 15th-century and rewards a slow look: notable stained glass, memorials, a historic porch and a Lady Chapel. The churchyard holds the reputed grave of Little John, a long-standing local legend rather than a proven fact, and part of the fun is treating it that way.
Charlotte Bronte stayed at the Hathersage vicarage for three weeks in the summer of 1845, visiting her friend Ellen Nussey. The church, the Eyre family graves, nearby buildings and the surrounding landscape supplied her with names and material that surface in Jane Eyre. The fictional village of Morton is often associated with Hathersage.